Discussion
Presently, there is an unresolved
dispute regarding real estate billionaires who pay lower income rates than
their employees. At the same time, they give advice on the amount of income tax
that other people should pay (Hannon, 2015). The dispute lies in the
inadequacies of the prevailing codes that allow the wealthy to accumulate vast
properties yet they pay little or no tax. A point worth noting is that most of
the tax avoidance scams are perfectly legal. In recent years, there have been
claims that financial experts have come up with numerous theories that allow
real estate tycoons to accumulate property without meeting their tax
obligations. Unfortunately, middle-income earners continue to pay high income
taxes, despite earning much less. In effect, there is a perception in the
United States that the rich avoid paying taxes, while the relatively poor pay
through the teeth. The current taxation system is, thus, unfair. Ideally, those
who earn more should pay higher taxes than those who earn less. However, real
estate investors in the United States continue to evade the taxman, as
middle-income earners drive the economy with their taxes. Therefore, there is a
need to level the playing field and distribute the tax burden equitably to
ensure that the government gets the revenues it requires to meet its
obligations without oppressing any section of the society, while favoring the
other.
There have been claims that tax
avoidance is beneficial to both individuals and firms alike. One of the prominent
concepts is “No Income Means No Tax,†which means that the biggest income tax
loophole is the definition of an individual’s income (Petrova &Ling, 2008).
The majority of the people assume that their income is their salary and bonuses.
However, the wealthy perceive salary as trivial if at all they receive any,
because their riches come from the appreciation of their real estate investments
among other assets. It is worth noting that the wealth of real estate magnets increases
by hundreds of millions annually. Unfortunately, tax codes do not define this appreciation
is as income. Therefore, it is not subject to income tax (Trumny, 2016). Further,
the taxes due from real estate income are effectively taxed lower than those on
salaries and bonuses. In addition, increases in the value of shares in the real
estate sector are not liable to taxation, unless one sells them. If they remain
unsold, the owners do not account for them. This is advantageous to real estate
investors, since no matter how much their wealth increases on paper, they do
not have to pay the government a penny until they seal a sale.
In
essence, the prevailing tax system in the United States does not impose taxes
on wealth. Typically, real estate investors receive small salaries relative to
their total compensation for their shares. The ownership share is the carried
interest. Notably, it receives a preferential treatment as capital gain instead
of income tax. When real estate investors’ tax bill is due, they owe the
federal government twenty 20% of the long-term capital gains tax rates, rather
than the 39.6% tax applicable to ordinary income (Hannon, 2015). A clear
example is the loophole that Mitt Romney exploited when filing his tax returns
based on capital gains during his tenure at Bain Capital.
Unfortunately,
Congress’ efforts to find a solution to this issue have been futile, because of
lobbyists who are unwilling to pay more tax. Recently, Donald Trump, a U.S.
presidential candidate, refused to release his tax returns. He claimed that he could
not comply since he is under an Internal Revenue Service (IRS) audit. Trump’s
empire sits on a racket with loopholes, several tax breaks, and deferrals that
tend to make the real estate developers extremely rich by eliminating most of
their tax obligations. Trump plays a tricky, two-step strategy to evade taxes. For
example, he claims in his Financial Disclosure Report that he made around 10.3
million dollars from his property (Trumny, 2016). However, when it was time to
pay property taxes, he argued that his property was worth USD1.36M. Besides, he
won big because of charitable tax deductions that allow the property owners to
impose permanent conservation measures. These tax evasion strategies are common
among real estate moguls who can afford the services of tax lawyers. Therefore,
they exploit the available tax breaks, thus, protecting their wealth.
The Real Investment Trust was formed
with the objective of holding properties by providing the investors with the
opportunity of investing in real properties. However, by providing waivers on
the corporate level income tax on REITS to make the scheme more attractive the
congress created a tax avoidance loophole. This is because the liquidation of
the real estate assets was difficult and one was entitled to paying estate tax
before the sale of the property (Yinger, Bloom& Boersch-Supan, 2016).
According to Yinger et al., the income
from equity and debt investments receive preferential treatment, for instance,
there are discrepancies in the classification of income from cash flow during
the hold and sale period which impacts the rate at which the investors pay
taxes (2016).Also, the income tax is considered an ordinary tax while the
interest and ordinary income are taxed at a rate similar to the taxpayer's
marginal rate. The capital gains from the net profits upon sale also get taxed
at the taxpayer's marginal rate. Besides, there are tax consequences arising
from state’s regulations and tax requirements and the investors are required to
file in the state they have invested as long as there is a state income tax.
Tax experts have proposed several
ideas that could help correct the issue of tax avoidance in real estate and,
hence, increase federal revenues. Some of these strategies include adjusting
real estate depreciation schedules to match the economic conditions and
limiting the percentage of the property financed with the developer’s own
equity (Armstrong, Blouin, Jagolinzer & Larcker, 2015). This would mean
that only the manufacturers would have the permission to deduct the expense of
capital equipment in the year of purchase. The reform from the multi-year
depreciation deductions to the first year expensing would help spur economic
growth for every dollar of revenue lost, because it would remove the current
tax code bias. Consequently, it could increase productivity and create jobs for
Americans. Besides, a reduction of the incentive to donate to charity to avoid
taxation could result in a drop in the number of itemizers, hence, increasing
tax revenues in the country. It is worth noting that real estate investors
would continue to itemize and benefit from tax deductions. However, their
subsidy would be much lower than it presently is, because of the significant
reduction in tax rates.
The above-mentioned solution to tax
avoidance in the real estate sector is pragmatic. However, tax experts and
economists argue that the reforms should include additional legislation action
to prevent tax evasion (Armstrong et al., 2015). Therefore, there is no
consensus yet on the way forward on an issue that have left many poor Americans
feeling conned by their government. In the meantime, wealthy real estate owners
continue to enjoy their riches, as the debate on the topic ranges on with no
solution in sight. Clearly, tracking real estate transactions and sharing the
tax residency information to enable the IRS to cross-reference individual tax
records and identify those avoiding paying the proper fees is a viable solution
to the problem. Indeed, it could force real estate moguls to comply with tax
regulations, since they know that all their details are under IRS scrutiny.
Besides, reporting every real estate transaction directly to the IRS would
ensure that there are no illusions of getting away with the sale of the property,
because of the continuing crackdown. However, such reforms might not be
effective without the necessary legislation. Therefore, Congress must go beyond
self-interest and pass tax laws that enhance equity.
Additional articles
The destructive power of racism has been felt all over the world over the years in a great way. An issue has been in the public debate realm over the years with civil revolutions and other movements to foster change coming up. However, it is like ...How-to-prevent-racism …
Read ArticleGenetics of Autism Spectrum Disorder Abstract: In this paper I briefly will summarize current research articles and journals of authors in reference to the genetics of autism spectrum disorder. Outline of ho...Autism-Spectrum-Disorder …
Read ArticleBeing an island nation Japan for thousands of years has enjoyed the sea as its cultural and economic resource. Fishing has been one of Japan’s largest coastal industry and has supported a huge number of the population. The industry has been a so...Fishing-Industry-in-Japan …
Read Article